Core Skills Analysis
Performing Arts and Media Studies
- Ella developed critical observation skills by noticing differences and similarities between the live Broadway production of Smash and its TV series adaptation.
- She gained an understanding of the elements that differentiate stage performances from screen productions, such as acting styles, pacing, and set design.
- Ella practiced analytical thinking through comparing narrative interpretation and production values displayed in both mediums.
- She enhanced cultural literacy by engaging with a contemporary musical and its televised adaptation, deepening her appreciation for storytelling across formats.
Comparative Literature and Media
- Ella identified themes and character portrayals in the Broadway and TV versions and reflected on how medium influences storytelling choices.
- She exercised evaluation skills by assessing how the same story can be adapted to different formats with unique artistic decisions and audience impacts.
- Ella explored the relationship between original source material and adaptation, understanding creative liberties used for each platform.
- She learned to articulate differences in dramatic effect and presentation style, reinforcing her ability to communicate thoughtful comparisons.
Tips
To deepen Ella's understanding, encourage her to create a Venn diagram highlighting the unique and shared elements of the Broadway show and TV series. She could write a reflective essay or journal entry about how the live experience felt emotionally compared to watching on screen. Exploring behind-the-scenes documentaries or interviews with cast and crew from both versions would provide insight into production challenges and artistic intent. Additionally, acting out a favorite scene from both versions at home could help her appreciate how performance changes with medium and audience interaction.
Book Recommendations
- Stage Door: The Broadway Musical from Show Boat to Sondheim and Lloyd Webber by Thomas S. Hischak: An accessible guide covering the history and artistry behind Broadway musicals, illuminating how productions come to life on stage.
- Adaptation and Appropriation by Julie Sanders: This book introduces readers to concepts of adapting stories across media, exploring creative transformation from page to screen or stage.
- Musical Theatre: A History by John Kenrick: Offers a thorough look at musical theatre’s evolution, ideal for understanding context behind shows like Smash.
Learning Standards
- ELA.7.R.1.1: Cite textual evidence to support analysis of literary and media texts.
- MA.7.ML.1.1: Analyze multiple media formats to understand how stories are adapted.
- TH.7.C.1.3: Compare and contrast live theatre experiences with media performances.
- ELA.7.W.1.2: Write informative/explanatory texts using evidence from media.
Try This Next
- Create a side-by-side storyboard illustrating a scene from both the Broadway show and TV series, noting visual and emotional differences.
- Design a quiz with questions about production elements unique to theatre vs television based on the Smash comparison.