PDF

Overview — what we'll learn

Geometry shows proportions you can see; harmony makes those proportions audible. The monochord is like a ruler-and-compass for sound: by dividing a string you can hear the basic ratios that make musical intervals and build scales. If we have time, we'll do a paper-folding experiment that shows why the pure (just) intervals don't line up perfectly and why musicians often use tempered tuning.

Key ideas (short)

  • Sound pitch depends on frequency: higher frequency = higher note.
  • On a single string, frequency is roughly inversely proportional to string length: shorter string → higher pitch.
  • Certain simple fractions of the original length (like 1/2, 2/3, 3/4) give sound combinations that our ears call consonant (pleasant): these are the octave, fifth, and fourth.
  • Stacking some pure intervals (especially perfect fifths) doesn't line up exactly with stacking octaves — this mismatch is why tempered tuning exists.

What you need for a monochord demo

  • A single string or a tightly stretched rubber band/long shoelace across a board or box (something you can press down to change the sounding length).
  • A small movable bridge (a pencil, a popsicle stick, or a little block) to shorten the sounding string length.
  • A ruler or measuring tape (to measure lengths along the string).
  • A tuner app (optional) or just your ear.

Step-by-step: simple monochord experiments

  1. Make a string of total sounding length L (for example L = 60 cm). Pluck it and listen to the note. This is our reference pitch.
  2. Octave (ratio 1:2): Move the bridge so the sounding length is L/2 (half the original length). Pluck — the note sounds one octave higher. Explanation: frequency doubles when length halves (f ∝ 1/length).
  3. Perfect fifth (ratio 2:3): Set the sounding length to (2/3)L (use ruler: 60 cm × 2/3 = 40 cm). Pluck — this sounds the interval called a perfect fifth above the open string. Numerically: frequency changes by factor 3/2 (because f ∝ 1/length, shorter = higher f).
  4. Perfect fourth (ratio 3:4): Set sounding length to (3/4)L (e.g., 45 cm). Pluck — you hear the fourth. Frequency factor is 4/3.
  5. Try other simple ratios: a major third in simple just intonation is 4:5 (length 5/4 of something, or more conveniently set the sounding length to (4/5)L ≈ 48 cm), which sounds like a major third. The simpler the small integers in the ratio, the more consonant the interval often sounds.

Where scales come from

If you keep dividing and combining these simple ratios, you can build a set of pitches that repeat every octave. For example, the Pythagorean method builds notes by stacking perfect fifths (ratio 3:2) and reducing them into the same octave. That produces many familiar notes, but not all small-number ratios will match each other perfectly when you combine them many times.

Why tempered tuning is needed — the idea

Musicians want instruments that can play in many keys (scales) without some notes sounding badly out of tune. Pure (just) intervals like perfect fifths are made from simple fractions, but if you stack 12 perfect fifths you do not end up exactly at 7 octaves. The small difference between these two results is the heart of the tuning problem.

Paper-folding experiment (hands-on) — demonstrates the mismatch between 12 pure fifths and 7 octaves

Goal: show physically that multiplying the length by 2/3 twelve times is not exactly the same as halving it seven times. You will see why equal (tempered) steps are used instead of only pure ratios.

Materials

  • A long strip of paper (a long receipt tape, a roll of paper, or stick together several sheets to make a long strip)—the longer the better; try to be able to fold/cut it many times.
  • Scissors, pencil, ruler (optional), tape.
  • A calculator (or phone calculator) for number checking.

Method

  1. Label one end of the strip "Start" and the other end "End." The full length is L (we'll treat L = 1 for calculations but measure actual paper in cm).
  2. We want to make a piece that represents length (2/3)L: to do that, fold the strip into 3 equal parts (there is a paper method: fold a corner down and adjust until you make three equal-looking sections, then flatten; or measure and divide by 3 with a ruler), then cut or mark so that one piece is 1/3 and the remaining part is 2/3. Set aside the (2/3)L piece — this represents doing one perfect fifth.
  3. Now to simulate stacking perfect fifths, repeat the process: from that 2/3 piece, fold it into 3 equal parts and take two of those parts (which gives (2/3)^2 of L). Keep repeating this division-into-3 and selecting two parts twelve times total. Each time you do that you are multiplying the length by 2/3, so after 12 times you have L × (2/3)^12.
  4. Separately, take a fresh piece of paper of length L and fold it in half seven times (each halving simulates going up an octave). After 7 halvings you have L × (1/2)^7 = L/128 — that corresponds to seven octaves.
  5. Compare the final lengths: the result of 12 stacked fifths (the repeated 2/3 pieces) will be slightly longer than the result of 7 octaves (the repeated halves). Physically you will see they do not match and they don't line up when put end to end.

What the numbers say (you can calculate or check with a calculator)

  • After 12 perfect fifths in frequency terms you multiply frequency by (3/2)^12. In length terms (since length ∝ 1/frequency) you multiply length by (2/3)^12 ≈ 1 / 129.746 ≈ 0.007707.
  • After 7 octaves frequency multiplies by 2^7 = 128, so length multiplies by (1/2)^7 = 1/128 ≈ 0.0078125.
  • The ratio (3/2)^12 / 2^7 ≈ 1.01364 — a tiny but audible difference (about 23.4 cents). That means 12 perfect fifths do not equal 7 octaves exactly.

Conclusion — what this shows and why equal temperament is used

Because simple pure intervals (like the perfect fifth) don't close up neatly when you keep stacking them, tuning systems must decide where to put the tiny imperfections. Equal temperament spreads the difference evenly: it divides the octave into 12 exactly equal steps in frequency (each semitone multiplies frequency by the 12th root of 2, about 1.05946). That means every key will be slightly adjusted, but instruments can play in any key and sound reasonably in tune.

Takeaway in plain words

  • The monochord makes visible the math behind intervals: halves, thirds, quarters give the octave, fifth, fourth, etc.
  • Simple ratios make nice-sounding intervals, but they do not all fit together perfectly when you build an entire 12-note keyboard using only some of them.
  • The paper-folding demo physically shows the mismatch that forces a compromise — equal temperament — used by most modern instruments so they can play in many keys without big clashes.

If you'd like, I can give: a detailed plan and pictures for building a simple classroom monochord, a printable sheet with the fold/cut steps for the paper experiment, or a small interactive table of ratios and the notes they give. Which would help most?


Ask a followup question

Loading...