Lesson Plan: More Than a Mudslide
Topic: How social, cultural, and economic factors influence the effects of geomorphic hazards.
Student: Heidi, age 13 (Homeschool)
Estimated Time: 2 - 2.5 hours
Materials Needed
- A shoebox or other small cardboard box
- Various craft supplies (e.g., construction paper, clay, paint, markers, small pebbles, popsicle sticks, cotton balls, glue, scissors)
- Tablet or computer with internet access for research
- Notebook and pen/pencil
1. Learning Objectives
By the end of this lesson, Heidi will be able to:
- Define a geomorphic hazard and identify three examples.
- Analyze a real-world case study of a geomorphic hazard.
- Explain at least three specific social, cultural, or economic factors that made the hazard's impact better or worse.
- Create a unique project (a "Split Scene" Diorama) to visually represent the connection between a physical event and its human consequences.
2. Warm-Up: "Disaster Dash" (5-10 minutes)
Goal: To get Heidi thinking about how resources and choices impact survival during a hazard.
Activity: Present Heidi with a quick scenario. "Imagine a major earthquake has just been forecast for our area, expected to hit in one hour. You can only grab five items from the house before we have to move to a safer, open space. What five items do you choose and why?"
Discussion Questions:
- Why did you choose those items?
- What if we didn't have access to a car to leave? How would your choices change?
- What if we didn't have money to buy supplies like bottled water or batteries beforehand?
Teacher's Note: This quick exercise immediately introduces the idea that a hazard isn't just about the shaking ground—it's about people's ability to prepare and respond, which is tied to their situation (their "socio-economic factors").
3. The Big Idea: It's a Human Story (15 minutes)
Goal: To clearly define the core concepts of the lesson using a comparative example.
Direct Instruction & Discussion:
- Define Geomorphic Hazard: Explain that this is a fancy term for a disaster caused by the Earth's natural processes. Ask Heidi to brainstorm examples (earthquakes, landslides, volcanic eruptions, tsunamis, avalanches, etc.).
- Introduce the Core Question: "If the exact same 7.0 magnitude earthquake hit two different cities, would the outcome be the same? Why or why not?"
- Compare and Contrast: Use the example of the 2010 Haiti Earthquake vs. the 2011 Christchurch, New Zealand Earthquake.
- Haiti (Poorer Nation): Lower building quality standards, less government organization for disaster response, limited medical resources, poverty. This led to a catastrophic loss of life and a very slow recovery.
- Christchurch (Wealthier Nation): Strict building codes, well-funded and organized emergency services, public awareness campaigns, strong economy for rebuilding. While still devastating, the impact on human life and the speed of recovery were vastly different.
- Define Key Factors: Explain that the differences are due to:
- Economic Factors: Wealth, poverty, quality of infrastructure (roads, hospitals, power grids).
- Social Factors: How well a community is organized, level of education, access to information, government stability and trust.
- Cultural Factors: How people view hazards (e.g., as a part of life vs. a rare event), community traditions of helping one another, language barriers.
4. Main Activity: The "Split Scene" Diorama & News Report (90 minutes)
Goal: To apply the concepts creatively through research and a hands-on project.
Part A: The Mission Briefing & Research (30 mins)
Your Mission: "Heidi, you are a field journalist sent to cover a major geomorphic event. Your editor doesn't just want to see the damage; she wants to understand the human story. Your job is to create a 3D 'Split Scene' report that shows both the physical event and the human factors that shaped the disaster."
Step 1: Choose Your Case Study. Heidi can pick one of the following:
- The 2010 Haiti Earthquake: A story of extreme vulnerability.
- The 2011 Tōhoku Earthquake & Tsunami (Japan): A story of extreme hazard vs. extreme preparedness.
- The 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami (affecting Indonesia, Thailand, etc.): A story of lack of warning systems and international impact.
Step 2: Research. Using a tablet or computer, Heidi should research her chosen event. Guide her with these questions:
- The Hazard: What happened physically? (e.g., What was the magnitude? How high were the waves? What areas were affected?)
- The Impact: What was the immediate damage? (e.g., buildings destroyed, lives lost).
- The Human Factors:
- Economic: Were the buildings in the area well-built or poorly constructed? Was it a wealthy or poor region? What was the condition of roads and hospitals?
- Social/Cultural: Was there an official warning system? Did people know what to do? How did the government respond? How did communities help each other?
Part B: The Creation (60 mins)
Step 1: Build the Diorama. Using the shoebox and craft supplies, Heidi will create her "Split Scene."
- Place a cardboard divider in the middle of the shoebox.
- Side 1: The Physical Hazard. This side is a purely physical model of the event. (e.g., cracked earth made of clay, a big wave from blue paper, a landslide of small pebbles).
- Side 2: The Human Story. This side shows the consequences as shaped by the human factors she researched. (e.g., For Haiti, it might show collapsed, simple buildings and people in makeshift tents. For Japan, it might show a damaged but still-standing earthquake-resistant building and an organized evacuation route sign).
Step 2: Write the News Report. While building, or after, Heidi should write a script for a 1-2 minute "on-the-scene" news report. The script must explain both sides of her diorama, explicitly connecting the physical event on one side to the socio-economic situation shown on the other. She should be prepared to present it.
5. Presentation & Reflection: "Live from the Scene" (15 minutes)
Goal: To assess understanding and consolidate learning through articulation.
Activity: Heidi presents her "Split Scene" diorama and delivers her news report as if she were a journalist on TV.
Debriefing Questions after her report:
- That was a fantastic report. What was the most surprising or interesting factor you discovered in your research?
- If you were in charge of that country, what is the first thing you would do to reduce the impact of a future disaster, based on what you learned?
- Why is it important for rescue workers and aid organizations (like the Red Cross) to understand a country's culture and economy before they go to help?
6. Assessment
Heidi's understanding will be assessed based on:
- The Diorama: Does it creatively and accurately distinguish between the physical hazard and the human consequences?
- The News Report: Can she clearly articulate the link between the hazard and at least three socio-economic factors?
- The Discussion: Her answers to the reflection questions will reveal the depth of her critical thinking on the topic.
7. Extension Activity (Optional)
Challenge: "The Resilience Blueprint."
On a new sheet of paper, ask Heidi to create a "Resilience Blueprint" for the community in her diorama. She should design a plan with 3-5 concrete ideas to help them be safer next time. The key is that these ideas must address the specific social or economic problems she identified (e.g., "start a program to teach builders earthquake-safe techniques," "create a community-run text message warning system," or "fundraise for a better-stocked local clinic"). This pushes her from analysis to problem-solving.