Procedural Writing Lesson Plan: The Cupcake Challenge (Ages 9-12)

Make learning procedural writing a delicious treat! This complete, hands-on lesson plan uses the fun activity of baking cupcakes to teach students ages 9-12 how to write clear, sequential instructions. Includes learning objectives, materials, and differentiation ideas.

Create Your Own Custom Lesson Plan
Previous Lesson
PDF

The Cupcake Challenge: Mastering Procedural Writing

Subject: Language Arts (Procedural Writing)

Suggested Time: 90-120 minutes (including baking/cooling time)

Appropriate for: Ages 9-12

Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, you will be able to:

  • Identify the key features of a procedural text (title, goal, materials, ordered steps).
  • Follow a multi-step procedure accurately to achieve a desired outcome.
  • Write a clear, sequential procedural text using imperative verbs (action words).

Materials Needed

For Baking:

  • A simple vanilla cupcake recipe (printed out)
  • All necessary cupcake ingredients (flour, sugar, eggs, butter, milk, vanilla, baking powder)
  • Cupcake liners and pan
  • Mixing bowls, measuring cups/spoons, whisk/mixer
  • Oven
  • Frosting (store-bought or homemade)
  • Sprinkles, food coloring, and other decorating supplies

For Writing:

  • Paper, pen, or pencil
  • Optional: A procedural writing template or graphic organizer with sections for Title, Goal, Materials, and Steps.
  • Whiteboard or large paper for brainstorming (optional)

Lesson Plan

Part 1: Introduction (10 minutes)

Hook: The Mixed-Up Mission

Ask the learner: "Imagine your friend gave you instructions to build a super cool LEGO spaceship. But they gave you the steps out of order: 'Put the wings on. Get the pieces out of the box. Add the pilot.' Would you be able to build the spaceship correctly? Why not?"

Discuss how the order of steps is crucial. This leads into the idea of "procedural writing," which is just a fancy name for writing instructions.

Stating the Objectives

"Today, we are going on a mission to become expert instruction writers! It’s called The Cupcake Challenge. Our mission has three parts:

  1. First, we'll become detectives and investigate a recipe to find its secret parts.
  2. Next, we'll test those instructions by baking actual cupcakes.
  3. Finally, you will become the chef and write your very own instructions for decorating the ultimate cupcake!"

Part 2: Body of the Lesson (60-90 minutes)

Activity 1: Deconstruct the Recipe (I Do, We Do - 15 mins)

I Do (Educator Explains):

"All good instructions, like recipes or game rules, have the same secret code. They have four key parts:

  • A Title: Tells you what you're making (e.g., 'Awesome Vanilla Cupcakes').
  • A Goal or Summary: A short sentence about the final product (e.g., 'This recipe makes 12 fluffy cupcakes').
  • Materials/Ingredients: A list of everything you need *before* you start.
  • Numbered Steps: The actions you need to take, in the right order. These steps almost always start with 'bossy verbs' like Mix, Pour, Bake, or Stir. They tell you exactly what to do."

We Do (Explore Together):

Hand the learner the printed cupcake recipe. "Okay, Detective, let's crack this recipe's code together. Using a pencil or highlighter:"

  • "Can you find and circle the Title?"
  • "Underline the Goal. What are we trying to achieve?"
  • "Put a star next to the Materials list. Why is it important to have this at the beginning?"
  • "Now for the most important part: the Steps. Let's read through them and highlight all the 'bossy verbs' we can find. I see 'Preheat,' 'Combine,' 'Mix'..."

This interactive analysis makes the structure of the text clear and tangible.

Activity 2: Follow the Procedure (Hands-On Practice - 30 mins + baking time)

"Now it's time to test these instructions! You are the Head Chef. Your job is to read each step out loud and lead the way. I'll be your assistant chef."

Guide the learner through the baking process, ensuring they follow the steps sequentially. Emphasize the importance of each step.

Formative Assessment Check-in: As you bake, ask questions like:

  • "What do you think would happen if we added the eggs before creaming the butter and sugar?"
  • "The instructions say 'mix until just combined.' Why is that specific detail important?"
  • "Why is preheating the oven the very first step?"

This reinforces the logic and importance of clear, ordered instructions.

Activity 3: Create a New Procedure (You Do - 15 mins while cupcakes cool)

"The cupcakes look amazing! While they cool, you get to be the recipe creator. Your challenge is to write the instructions for decorating one of these cupcakes with your own unique design. You need to write a procedure so clear that I could follow it perfectly without any extra help."

Provide the learner with paper or a template. Guide them through the writing process:

  1. Brainstorm: "First, let's give your design a cool name. 'The Rainbow Sprinkle Volcano?' 'The Chocolate Zig-Zag Surprise?' That will be your Title."
  2. List Materials: "What will I need to make your design? List everything: one plain cupcake, chocolate frosting, rainbow sprinkles, etc."
  3. Write the Steps: "Now, write down the steps in order. Remember to start each step with a 'bossy verb.' For example:
    1. Spread the frosting evenly on the cupcake.
    2. Place three chocolate chips in the center.
    3. Sprinkle the rainbow sprinkles around the edge.

Success Criteria: Let the learner know what makes a great set of instructions: "I will know you've succeeded when your procedure has a title, a materials list, at least 3 numbered steps, and each step starts with an action word (a bossy verb)."

Part 3: Conclusion (15 minutes)

Recap and Share

Once the learner has finished writing, ask them to share their procedure. "Let's review our mission. What are the four key parts of any procedural text?" (Title, Goal/Intro, Materials, Steps). "What kind of words do we use to start our steps?" (Bossy verbs/action words).

Summative Assessment: The Decoration Test!

The ultimate test! The educator now takes the learner's written instructions and follows them *exactly* as written to decorate a cupcake. This is a fun and powerful way to assess the clarity of their writing. If a step is unclear, talk about how it could be improved.

Then, the learner decorates their own cupcake. Of course, the final step is to enjoy the delicious results of your hard work!

Differentiation and Adaptations

  • For Learners Needing More Support:
    • Provide a sentence-starter template for the writing portion (e.g., "1. First, you need to ______.").
    • Offer a word bank of "bossy verbs" (Spread, Place, Drizzle, Sprinkle, Add, etc.).
    • Act as a scribe, writing down the steps as the learner dictates them, keeping the focus on their ability to sequence the actions verbally.
  • For Learners Seeking a Challenge:
    • Challenge them to add a "Tips & Tricks" section to their decorating guide.
    • Ask them to write the procedure for a more complex task, like cleaning up the kitchen after baking, including at least 5 steps.
    • Have them create diagrams or drawings to go along with their written steps to make them even clearer.

Ask a question about this lesson