News Detectives Lesson Plan: Analyzing Informational Text & Author's Purpose

Empower students to become critical thinkers with this engaging "News Detectives" lesson plan. Teach learners how to analyze informational texts, identify the author's purpose and point of view, and evaluate evidence in real-world articles. This complete resource includes a printable graphic organizer, guided activities, and differentiation strategies for upper elementary and middle school.

Create Your Own Custom Lesson Plan
Previous Lesson
PDF

Lesson Plan: News Detectives - Analyzing Real-World Issues

Materials Needed:

  • Three short, age-appropriate informational articles about a single, interesting topic (e.g., the four-day school week, the effects of video games, or Should plastic straws be banned?). Make sure the articles have a clear point of view.
  • Highlighters or colored pencils (at least two different colors)
  • "News Detective" Graphic Organizer (template provided below)
  • Notebook or digital document for writing
  • Pen or pencil

Learning Objectives:

By the end of this lesson, you will be able to:

  • Identify the main idea and key supporting details in an informational text.
  • Analyze an author's purpose and point of view on a real-world issue.
  • Evaluate the evidence an author uses to support their claims.
  • Formulate your own opinion on the issue, supported by evidence from the text.

Lesson Activities

I. Introduction: The Hook (10 minutes)

Educator-Led Discussion:

"Have you ever scrolled through a news site or social media and seen two totally different headlines about the same event? One might say, 'New Video Game Boosts Brain Power!' and another might say, 'Video Games Linked to Poor Grades!' How can both be true? Who should you believe?"

"Today, we're going to become 'News Detectives.' Our job isn't just to read the news, but to investigate it. We'll learn how to figure out what an author is really trying to say, what their opinion is, and whether they have good evidence to back it up. This is a superpower for navigating the world, because it helps you think for yourself and not just believe everything you read."

Review Objectives:

"Our goals today are to practice finding the main point, spotting the author's opinion, checking their evidence, and then forming our own smart opinion."

II. Body: The Investigation (30-40 minutes)

Part 1: I Do - Modeling the Detective Work (10 minutes)

Educator Models the Skill:

"Okay, let's look at our first article together. I'm going to read it out loud and think like a detective. I'll use my highlighters and the 'News Detective' graphic organizer."

(Educator takes the first, simplest article and a blank graphic organizer.)

  1. "First, I'll read through the whole article one time just to get the gist."
  2. "Now, I'll read it again. This time, I'm hunting for the main idea. This is the big point the author is trying to make. I'm looking for a sentence that sums everything up, often near the beginning or end. Ah, here it is. I'll highlight it in yellow." (Educator highlights the main idea and writes it in the organizer.)
  3. "Next, I need key details. These are the facts, stats, or examples the author uses to support that main idea. I'll highlight at least three of these in green." (Educator highlights details and jots them down.)
  4. "Now for the tricky part: the author's purpose and point of view. Are they just trying to inform me, or are they trying to persuade me to agree with them? Based on the words they use, like 'clearly' and 'a terrible idea,' I think they are trying to persuade me. Their point of view is that they are AGAINST this topic." (Educator fills this in.)
  5. "Finally, I need to evaluate the evidence. Are these strong facts, or just opinions? This detail is a statistic from a study—that's strong evidence! This other one is just a quote from one person—that might be weaker evidence because it's just one person's opinion." (Educator fills in the organizer.)

Part 2: We Do - Guided Investigation (10-15 minutes)

Guided Practice:

"Now it's your turn to help. Let's look at the second article together. We'll fill out a new graphic organizer step-by-step."

  1. "You read the first paragraph. What do you think the main idea might be? Which sentence should we highlight in yellow?"
  2. "Great. Now, as we read the rest, call out any key details you see that support this main idea. What should we highlight in green?"
  3. "Let's talk about the author's purpose. What clues in the text tell you what the author wants you to believe? Are they for or against the topic? How do you know?"
  4. "Look at the evidence we highlighted. On a scale of 1 to 5, how strong is this evidence? Why?"

Part 3: You Do - Solo Mission (10-15 minutes)

Independent Practice & Formative Assessment:

"You've got the skills, detective. Here is the third article. Your mission is to analyze it on your own using a fresh graphic organizer. Take your time, use your highlighters, and fill in each section of the worksheet. This is where you show me what you've learned."

Success Criteria:

  • You have clearly identified and written down the main idea.
  • You have listed at least three relevant key details from the text.
  • You have made a reasonable guess about the author's purpose and point of view.
  • You have rated the evidence and explained your rating.

III. Conclusion: Debriefing the Case (10 minutes)

Share and Recap:

"Okay, Detective, report your findings! Tell me about the article you just analyzed. What was the main idea? What was the author's point of view?"

(Learner shares their completed graphic organizer. Educator provides feedback.)

Discussion and Real-World Connection:

  • "So today we looked at a few articles on the same topic. Did they all agree?"
  • "Now for the most important question: Based on all the evidence you've seen, what is your opinion on this issue? Why? Use some of the evidence from the articles to back up your thoughts."
  • "How can you use this 'News Detective' skill every day when you're reading things online, watching videos, or even just talking to people?"

"Awesome work today. You've learned that reading isn't just about understanding words; it's about understanding the world and thinking critically. You're now better equipped to be a smart, informed citizen."

Assessment

  • Formative: Observations during the "We Do" guided practice and questions asked throughout the lesson.
  • Summative: The completed "News Detective" graphic organizer from the "You Do" independent practice serves as the primary assessment of the learning objectives. The learner's ability to articulate their own evidence-based opinion in the conclusion also demonstrates mastery.

Differentiation

  • Scaffolding for Struggling Learners: Provide an article that is shorter or has a more obvious main idea. You can also pre-highlight the key details and have the learner focus only on analyzing the author's purpose and point of view. Provide sentence starters in the graphic organizer (e.g., "The author's main idea is that...").
  • Extension for Advanced Learners: Ask the learner to find a fourth article on the same topic online. Have them analyze it and then write a short paragraph comparing and contrasting the arguments and evidence used across two different articles. They could also research one of the facts presented in an article to verify if it is accurate.

"News Detective" Graphic Organizer Template

Article Title: _____________________________________________________

Author: __________________________________________________________

1. What is the author's MAIN IDEA? (The single biggest point they are trying to make.)

2. What are 3 KEY DETAILS or pieces of evidence the author uses to support the main idea?

3. What is the AUTHOR'S PURPOSE and POINT OF VIEW? (Are they trying to inform, persuade, or entertain? Are they FOR or AGAINST the topic?)

4. How strong is the author's evidence? (Circle one and explain why.)

Weak         Okay         Strong

Why?

5. My Questions & Thoughts: (What does this article make me wonder about?)

Ask a question about this lesson