The Mars Outpost: Rules for a New World
Materials Needed
- Paper and pens/markers
- A timer (phone or kitchen timer)
- Two small items to act as "tokens" (coins, buttons, or LEGO bricks)
Learning Objectives
By the end of this lesson, you will be able to:
- Identify and define Decision-Making, Inclusion, and Justice rules.
- Apply these rules to solve a complex resource problem in a fictional scenario.
- Evaluate how different rules create different outcomes for a community.
1. Introduction: The Blank Slate (3 Minutes)
The Hook: Imagine you have just landed on Mars. There are no laws, no government, and no "boss" yet. You and a small group of people have to build a society from scratch. If you don't have rules, things will get messy fast. But what kind of rules do you need?
The Goal: Today, we aren't just making "don't run in the halls" rules. We are making Foundational Rules that determine how your new world actually functions.
2. I Do: The Three Pillars of a Society (5 Minutes)
To keep our Mars colony from turning into chaos, we need three specific types of rules. Let's define them:
- Rule 1: Decision-Making Rule
Definition: This tells us how we make a choice when people disagree.
Example: "Majority Rules" (51% wins) or "Consensus" (Everyone must agree). - Rule 2: Inclusion Rule
Definition: This tells us who gets to be involved and how we make sure no one is left out.
Example: "Every age group must have a representative in the meeting." - Rule 3: Justice Rule
Definition: This tells us what happens when a rule is broken or someone is treated unfairly.
Example: "If you break it, you must spend your weekend helping fix it" (Restorative Justice).
3. We Do: The Pizza Party Paradox (7 Minutes)
Let's practice together using a relatable scenario. Imagine our colony has one extra pizza, but there are 10 hungry people.
Let’s apply our rules:
- Inclusion: Before we decide who eats, we check our Inclusion Rule. Rule: Every person must be present in the room before the box is opened. Why? To ensure the quietest person isn't forgotten in the back of the lab.
- Decision-Making: Now we have to choose a topping. Rule: Rank Choice. Everyone lists their top 3. The one with the most total points wins. This is fairer than just the loudest person screaming "Pepperoni!"
- Justice: Someone took two slices when they were only supposed to take one. Rule: The "Give Back" Rule. That person must give their dessert to the person who didn't get a full slice. It fixes the imbalance.
Discussion: Does this feel "fair"? Why or why not?
4. You Do: The Mars Outpost Challenge (10 Minutes)
The Scenario: A massive dust storm is approaching the Mars Outpost. You only have enough backup battery power to keep ONE of these three sections running at full capacity:
- The Greenhouse: Keeps the plants (food) alive.
- The Oxygen Lab: Keeps the air fresh (but we have 48 hours of bottled air left).
- The Communication Hub: Allows you to talk to Earth for help.
Your Task: You must decide which section gets the power. However, you must follow these specific rules to make your decision. Write down your final choice and a brief explanation of how the rules changed your thinking.
The Mandatory Rules:
- Decision-Making Rule (The 70% Rule): You cannot make a choice unless 70% of your colony (represented by your left and right hand "tokens") agree. If your tokens "disagree," you must find a compromise.
- Inclusion Rule (The Expert Voice): You must write down one "Pro" and one "Con" for every section before choosing. No section can be ignored.
- Justice Rule (The Shared Sacrifice): Whatever section you shut down, the leaders (you!) must give up your personal luxury items (like your tablet or special snacks) to the workers of that section as a "thank you" for their hardship.
Success Criteria:
1. You have a final decision written down.
2. You have a list of Pros/Cons for all three sections (Inclusion).
3. You can explain how you would "make it right" for the people in the darkened sections (Justice).
5. Conclusion: Recap & Reflection (2 Minutes)
Summary: Today we learned that a fair society isn't just about "being nice." It's about having systems in place:
- Decision-making to prevent arguments.
- Inclusion to ensure everyone is seen.
- Justice to fix things when they break.
Final Question: Which of the three rules was the hardest to follow in your Mars scenario? Why?
Differentiation Options
- For Advanced Learners: Add a "Scarcity Modifier." What if a fourth rule is added mid-challenge: "A secret vote is taken, and 20% of the colony wants to hoard the power for themselves." How does your Justice rule handle greed?
- For Struggling Learners: Simplify the scenario to "Choosing a Movie for a Group" using the same three rule types to practice the concepts in a lower-stakes environment.